Why Moissanite, Lab-Grown Diamonds, and Natural Diamonds Are Smarter Investments Than Cubic Zirconia

Why Moissanite, Lab-Grown Diamonds, and Natural Diamonds Are Smarter Investments Than Cubic Zirconia

When shopping for fine jewelry — whether it’s an engagement ring, anniversary gift, or a piece to celebrate yourself — the stone you choose makes all the difference. While cubic zirconia (CZ) is often marketed as a budget-friendly option, it simply can’t compete with the long-term value, brilliance, and durability of moissanite, lab-grown diamonds, or natural diamonds.

At Mallard & Co Jewelers, we believe jewelry should be both beautiful and meaningful — something that tells a story and lasts for years to come. Here’s why investing in moissanite, lab-grown diamonds, or natural diamonds is always the smarter choice over cubic zirconia.

The Truth About Durability

One of the most important factors when choosing a gemstone is its hardness — how resistant it is to scratching and wear.

  • Natural Diamonds (10 Mohs): The hardest natural material on Earth, known for lasting generations.

  • Lab-Grown Diamonds (10 Mohs): Identical in strength and durability to mined diamonds.

  • Moissanite (9.25 Mohs): Nearly as hard as diamonds, making it an excellent daily-wear gemstone.

  • Cubic Zirconia (8–8.5 Mohs): Softer and more prone to scratches, chips, and clouding.

👉 Jewelry is meant to last. With CZ, you’ll likely replace your piece within a few years. With diamonds or moissanite, you’ll enjoy a lifetime of sparkle.

Brilliance That Lasts

Sparkle isn’t just about beauty — it’s about endurance.

  • Moissanite: Famous for its fiery brilliance, often outshining diamonds with rainbow flashes of light.

  • Lab & Natural Diamonds: Offer the classic white sparkle that has symbolized love and luxury for centuries.

  • Cubic Zirconia: Looks bright at first but dulls quickly with daily wear, losing the “wow factor” it once had.

👉 Moissanite and diamonds continue to shine year after year, while CZ fades into a dull reminder that it was the “cheap” option.

Real Value, Real Investment

Jewelry is more than decoration — it’s an investment.

  • Natural Diamonds: Known to retain or even appreciate in value. Perfect for heirlooms and future generations.

  • Lab-Grown Diamonds: More affordable than mined diamonds but still hold value and authenticity.

  • Moissanite: An accessible investment for buyers who want brilliance and durability without the high diamond price tag.

  • Cubic Zirconia: Has virtually no resale value. Considered disposable in the jewelry world.

👉 When you buy a diamond or moissanite, you’re putting your money into something lasting — not something you’ll throw away.

Emotional Significance

Jewelry often marks life’s biggest milestones: engagements, weddings, anniversaries, and achievements.

  • Diamonds & Moissanite: Represent strength, love, and endurance — perfect symbols for commitment and milestones.

  • Cubic Zirconia: Typically seen as costume jewelry, lacking the depth of meaning that fine gemstones carry.

👉 For the moments that matter most, a real investment gemstone speaks louder than imitation.

Eco-Friendly & Ethical Choices

Today’s buyers are more conscious than ever about where their jewelry comes from.

  • Lab-Grown Diamonds: A sustainable, ethical alternative to mined diamonds.

  • Moissanite: Lab-created and eco-friendly, offering brilliance without the environmental footprint.

  • Natural Diamonds: When sourced responsibly, they create livelihoods and maintain heirloom status.

  • Cubic Zirconia: While lab-made, it doesn’t provide the same ethical or sustainable prestige — mostly because it lacks long-term value.

Final Thoughts

While cubic zirconia may seem appealing upfront for its low cost, it simply doesn’t hold up in the long run. Moissanite, lab-grown diamonds, and natural diamonds are superior in durability, brilliance, emotional value, and investment potential.

At Mallard & Co Jewelers, we believe luxury doesn’t have to come at a $10,000 price tag — but it should look and feel like it does. That’s why we specialize in gemstones that bring lasting beauty, value, and meaning into every piece.

✨ Don’t settle for short-term shine. Choose forever brilliance.

Got it ✅ I’ll recreate the comparison table for you in a clean, professional format that fits an article for Mallard & Co Jewelers. You can copy-paste this into Shopify (or Canva if you’re making a graphic).

Here’s the table:

Comparing the Gems: Key Differences

Aspect Moissanite Lab-Grown Diamond Natural Diamond Cubic Zirconia (CZ)
Composition Silicon carbide (lab-created) Pure carbon (lab-grown) Pure carbon (mined) Zirconium dioxide (synthetic)
Hardness (Mohs) 9.25 – Very durable 10 – Hardest material 10 – Hardest material 8.5 – Prone to scratches
Sparkle & Fire Very high fire (2x diamond dispersion) Balanced brilliance & fire Classic white brilliance Sparkly but glassy appearance
Color & Clarity Mostly colorless; some tints Colorless options, often flawless Wide range (D–Z); natural inclusions Typically flawless & colorless
Durability Excellent for daily wear Eternal; ideal for everyday wear Timeless heirloom quality Scratches and clouds over time
Cost (1 ct) $300 – $1,000 $1,000 – $4,000 (30–40% less than natural) $2,000 – $20,000+ $10 – $100
Ethical Impact Eco-friendly (no mining) Sustainable; conflict-free Mining concerns (choose conflict-free) Minimal impact, but not a true gem
Resale Value Low Moderate High; investment-worthy Near zero

Prices are approximate for a 1-carat round brilliant gemstone as of 2025, based on jewelry industry data.

Back to blog